Treść książki

Przejdź do opcji czytnikaPrzejdź do nawigacjiPrzejdź do informacjiPrzejdź do stopki
CtesiasandtheImportanceofHisWritingsRevisited
11
Ctesias,hisreputationandtheinformationthathegives.13Aclearjudgmentisdifficultto
obtain,sinceCtesias’workshaveregrettablybeenlostandareonlypreservedinseveral
fragmentsfoundinafewauthors(likePlutarch).Thus,theoriginalcontentcannotbe
fathomedwithabsolutecertainty.Whatisclearisthatthroughhisinfluenceuponhis
immediatereaders,chiefamongthembeingXenophon,Ctesiasshouldbeseenasoneof
themostsignificantandcreativewritersofthefourthcenturyBCE.
CtesiaswasborninthesecondhalfofthefthcenturyBCE,14inCnidos(T2-4,
7c,11h,12),oneofthetwocentersofmedicalpracticeinclassicalGreece,15andthe
placewherehepresumablystudiedandpracticedthisoccupation.Hisfatherwasnamed
Ctesiochus(T1,11h)orCtesiarchus(T1).16Accordingtohisownreport,hewastaken
prisonerandbroughttothePersiancourtbecauseofhismedicalexpertise(Diod.2.32.4).
HisdeparturefromPersiainvolvedsomesortoftrickery;accordingtoCtesias’report,
hewasapparentlyinvolvedinmediationbetweenthekingontheonehandandEvago-
ras,kingofCyprianSalamis,andConon,theAthenianadmiral(andsoontobecome
anadmiralofthenewPersianeet)ontheother,andmadesurehewouldbeassigned
adiplomaticmission(Plut.Art.21.1-4;17cf.F30.72-4),anopportunityheusedtobring
abouthisescapefromPersiaandtheservicetotheGreatKing(398/397BCE,cf.Diod.
14.46.6);CtesiasdepartedonhiswaytoSparta,butsomehowwasdetainedinRhodes
(F30.75).18HemayhavesettledinSpartaorreturnedhome,toCnidus,19andmayalso
havecontinuedpracticingmedicine.20
appearsinNicolaosofDamascus,FGrH90F66,43-44.Butthisisnotnecessarilycorrect.Hamilton(1969:
liii,191)believesCtesiasisthesourceofPlutarch’sAlexander69.1.
13
ForahighopinionofCtesias’accountoftherevoltofInarosseethereferencesinBigwood1976:
1n.2.Cf.Cawkwell1972:39-40.ForCtesiasasbasicallytrustworthyonthetyrannicalandcapricious
ruthlessnessofrulersseeLewis1977:29.SeealsoStevenson1997:72(“basichonestyinthedescriptionof
contemporaryeventsinwhichhewasnotpersonallyinvolved”),75,81;Murray2001:42n.57;Dalley2003:
182;Lenfant2004:CXXIII;Llewellyn-Jones/Robson2010:53;Stronk2010:54.ForaviewthatseesCtesias
asfaithfullytransmittinglocaltraditionsseeMomigliano1931;cf.Lenfant1996.
14
15
Brown1978:10:between440and435.
SeeNutton2004:69-70.
16
ThereisclearlysomecorruptionofthenameintheMSStradition.Ctesias’fatherwasapparentlyalso
aphysician(cf.F68),andthefamilyregardeditselfasAsclepiad(T4:dV¢σKXnπidδngT{γέVog).Ctesias
wascontemporarytoHippocrates;cf.Lenfant,2004:VIII,andisdescribedasoneofhisrelatives(σUγγSV[g
OˆTo[scil.ºππoKPdToUg]).Cf.F67.
17
ItisclearthatthesecondversionPlutarchcitesat21.4,andaccordingtowhichthephysicianissaidto
insertasectionintoConon’sletter,suggestingthatCtesiaswouldbesenttoassisttheAthenianadmiral,does
notcomefromanotherauthor(contraHaug1854:98;Smith1881:4;Mantey1888:17;Brown1978:17;
Stevenson1997:117-118andBinder2008:284)butfromCtesiashimselfasataleillustratinganinstanceof
heroictrickery,modeledonOdysseusandothers.
18
AsLenfant(2004:xxii-xix)pointsout,thetrialmentioned(KO.KP.σigπP{gTogΛOKSδOiμoV.ωV
BγγέXoUgTVÑόδωi,KO.DφSσig:atRhodestherewasatrialconcerningtheSpartanenvoysfollowedbyan
acquittal)isinfactnotofCtesias,butoftheSpartandelegates,contraJacoby1922:2036;Brown1978:18;
Eck1990:423-424.Cf.Llewellyn-Jones/Robson2010:17.
19
Sparta:cf.Lenfant2004:XX-XIX;Cnidus:Brown1978:18;Lenfant2004:XXIII.
20
Brown1978:19.